Home » Current Affairs IAS » Farmers in West Bengal are shifting away from wheat and towards lucrative banana, lentil, and maize production. What’s the reason?

Farmers in West Bengal are shifting away from wheat and towards lucrative banana, lentil, and maize production. What’s the reason?

UPSC News Editorial : A New Harvest: Crop Diversification Reshapes West Bengal's Agriculture

Summary:

- Shift from Wheat to Lucrative Crops: Border districts are moving away from wheat cultivation and embracing crops like bananas, lentils, and maize due to economic viability.
- Increased Income and Sustainability: Alternative crops offer better income and diversification, improving overall sustainability.
  Challenges: Market access, technical knowledge, and government policies remain challenges.
- Government Initiatives: India’s schemes promote crop diversification.
- Importance of Yield and Prices: The shift reflects dynamism and highlights the need to consider yield per hectare alongside crop prices.

What is the news?

- West Bengal’s agricultural landscape is undergoing a significant transformation, particularly in the border districts bordering Bangladesh. Traditionally known for its wheat production, the region is witnessing a shift towards more lucrative crops like bananas, lentils, and maize.

- This editorial will explore the reasons behind this shift and its potential implications for the future of agriculture in West Bengal.

Drivers of Change: Why Wheat is Losing Ground

Several factors are contributing to the decline of wheat cultivation in West Bengal’s border districts:

- Economic Viability: As reported in editorial, wheat fetches growers a lower price per quintal compared to maize. However, the higher per-hectare output of maize makes it a more profitable crop overall. Additionally, the editorial highlights the potential for premium prices from poultry and food processing companies purchasing maize, further incentivizing farmers.
- Disease Threat: The emergence of wheat blast disease in neighboring Bangladesh in 2016 forced the West Bengal government to impose a temporary ban on wheat cultivation in border areas. While the ban has been lifted, the threat of the disease persists, making farmers hesitant to invest in wheat again.
- Water Scarcity: Wheat requires a significant amount of water for irrigation, putting a strain on water resources in the region. Crops like lentils and maize are more drought-resistant, making them a more sustainable option for farmers facing water scarcity.

Embracing New Opportunities: The Rise of Alternative Crops

The shift towards alternative crops offers several potential benefits for West Bengal’s farmers:

- Increased Income: Higher profit margins from bananas, lentils, and maize can improve the livelihoods of farmers and contribute to rural development.
- Crop Diversification: Diversifying crops reduces the risk of crop failure due to pests or weather events. This diversification can enhance the overall resilience of West Bengal’s agricultural sector.
- Improved Sustainability: Crops like lentils help improve soil fertility by fixing nitrogen, leading to long-term benefits for agricultural productivity. Additionally, crops with lower water requirements can contribute to sustainable water management practices.

Challenges and Considerations for the Future

While the shift towards alternative crops presents exciting opportunities, some challenges need to be addressed:

- Market Access and Infrastructure: Ensuring efficient market access and cold chain infrastructure is crucial for maximizing profits from perishable crops like bananas.
- Technical Know-How and Extension Services: Farmers may require training and support in cultivation practices, pest management, and post-harvest handling of new crops.
- Government Policies: Government policies that incentivize crop diversification and provide support for infrastructure development can play a vital role in promoting this shift.

Conclusion: A New Chapter for West Bengal’s Agriculture

- The shift towards alternative crops reflects the dynamism of West Bengal’s agricultural sector. Farmers are adapting to changing market conditions, environmental challenges, and government policies. By addressing the existing challenges and capitalizing on the potential benefits, this shift can pave the way for a more sustainable, profitable, and resilient agricultural future for West Bengal.
- This shift also highlights the importance of considering yield per hectare alongside crop prices. While wheat might fetch a higher price per quintal, the increased yield of maize makes it a more attractive option for farmers. This editorial emphasizes the need for government support in multiple areas. Encouraging crop diversification through policies and infrastructure development, along with providing extension services to equip farmers with the knowledge and skills to cultivate new crops effectively, will be crucial for the long-term success of this agricultural transformation.

Government Initiatives for Crop Diversification in India

- Crop diversification is a key strategy for improving the sustainability and profitability of Indian agriculture. The government has implemented various initiatives to encourage farmers to adopt this practice. Here’s a breakdown of some key programs:

Central Government Schemes:

- Mission for Integrated Development of Horticulture (MIDH): This mission promotes the production, protection, and processing of fruits, vegetables, flowers, and medicinal plants. It provides financial assistance for setting up nurseries, protected cultivation infrastructure, and market linkages.
- National Food Security Mission (NFSM): While focusing on staple crops like rice and wheat, NFSM also promotes diversification by providing incentives for pulses and oilseeds cultivation through input subsidies and price support mechanisms.
- Rashtriya Krishi Vikas Yojana (RKVY): This scheme provides financial assistance to states for various agricultural development activities, including promoting crop diversification through sub-schemes like the Crop Diversification Programme (CDP) in water-intensive regions.
- Pradhan Mantri Krishi Sinchai Yojana (PMKSY): This program focuses on micro-irrigation, which is crucial for promoting water-efficient crops like lentils and maize, thus encouraging diversification.

State Government Initiatives:

- Many state governments offer additional incentives for cultivating alternative crops. This could include subsidies on seeds, fertilizers, and micro-irrigation equipment.

- Some states provide technical support and training programs to educate farmers on cultivation practices and pest management for new crops.

- Initiatives like setting up farmer producer organizations (FPOs) can help with market access and collective bargaining for diversified crops.

Challenges and the Road Ahead:

- Despite these initiatives, there are challenges in promoting crop diversification. Ensuring proper market access and cold chain infrastructure for perishable items remains a concern.

- Providing adequate extension services and technical know-how to farmers for new crops is crucial for successful adoption.
  Streamlining government schemes and ensuring their effective implementation at the ground level is essential.

Conclusion:

- Government initiatives play a vital role in promoting crop diversification in India. By addressing the existing challenges and continuously improving these programs, the government can empower farmers to embrace this approach, leading to a more sustainable, profitable, and resilient agricultural sector.

What is Crop Diversification ? Explained in context with India

Crop diversification refers to the practice of cultivating a variety of crops on a particular farm, rather than focusing on just one or two. Here’s how it applies to India:

Benefits of Crop Diversification in India:

- Increased Income: Monoculture (focusing on a single crop) can leave farmers vulnerable to price fluctuations and poor harvests. Diversifying crops allows them to generate income from different sources, potentially increasing their overall profit margins. For example, crops like bananas offer higher profit margins compared to traditional staples like wheat.
- Reduced Risk: Different crops are susceptible to different pests and diseases. By diversifying, farmers reduce the risk of a complete crop failure if one variety is affected by an issue. This is especially important in the face of unpredictable weather patterns.
- Improved Soil Health: Growing the same crop repeatedly can deplete essential nutrients from the soil. Certain crops, like legumes, can help fix nitrogen in the soil, improving its fertility for future harvests. This promotes sustainable agricultural practices.
- Water Management: Some crops, like wheat, require a lot of water for irrigation. Diversification allows farmers to integrate more drought-resistant crops like lentils and maize, which can be a better option in water-scarce regions.

Challenges of Crop Diversification in India:

- Market Access: Selling a wider variety of crops requires efficient market access and cold chain infrastructure, especially for perishable items like fruits and vegetables. This infrastructure might not be readily available in all regions.
- Knowledge and Training: Shifting to new crops might require farmers to learn new cultivation techniques, pest management practices, and post-harvest handling methods. Government extension services and training programs can play a crucial role in supporting this transition.
- Government Policies: Government policies that incentivize crop diversification and provide support for infrastructure development can significantly encourage farmers to adopt this practice.

The Case of West Bengal:

- The news about West Bengal farmers shifting from wheat to bananas, lentils, and maize exemplifies the concept of crop diversification in action. Factors like stagnant wheat prices, disease threats, and water scarcity are pushing farmers towards more profitable and sustainable options. This shift holds promise for increased income, improved soil health, and better water management practices. However, ensuring market access, providing adequate training, and implementing supportive government policies are crucial for the long-term success of this agricultural transformation in West Bengal and across India.

(Editorial inspired by Down to Earth Magazine.)

QuizTime:

Mains Questions:

Question 1:

West Bengal farmers, particularly in border districts like Murshidabad and Nadia, are shifting from wheat cultivation to more lucrative options like bananas, lentils, and maize. Analyze the factors driving this shift and discuss the potential benefits and challenges associated with it.(250 words)

Model Answer:

Factors Driving the Shift:

- Economic Viability: Stagnant wheat prices coupled with rising production costs make wheat cultivation less profitable. Conversely, crops like bananas offer higher profit margins.
- Disease Threat: The emergence of wheat blast disease in neighboring Bangladesh poses a risk to wheat crops in West Bengal, discouraging farmers from relying on it.
- Water Scarcity: Wheat requires significant irrigation, putting a strain on water resources. Drought-resistant crops like lentils and maize are more sustainable options.

Potential Benefits:

- Increased Income: Higher profit margins from alternative crops can improve farmer livelihoods and contribute to rural development.
- Crop Diversification: Diversification reduces the risk of crop failure due to pests or weather events, leading to a more resilient agricultural sector.
- Improved Sustainability: Crops like lentils fix nitrogen in the soil, enhancing long-term fertility. Additionally, water-efficient crops promote sustainable water management.

Challenges:

- Market Access and Infrastructure: Ensuring efficient market access and cold chain infrastructure is crucial, especially for perishable crops like bananas.
- Technical Know-How: Farmers might require training and support in cultivation practices, pest management, and post-harvest handling of new crops.
- Government Policies: Supportive government policies that incentivize crop diversification and infrastructure development are necessary for long-term success.

Question 2:

Crop diversification is a key strategy for promoting sustainable agriculture in India. Discuss various government initiatives aimed at promoting crop diversification and analyze their effectiveness.(250 words)

Model Answer:

Government Initiatives:

- Central Schemes: MIDH, NFSM, RKVY (with CDP sub-scheme), PMKSY (micro-irrigation)
- State Initiatives: Subsidies, training programs, FPOs.

Effectiveness:

- Positives: Schemes provide financial assistance, promote water-efficient crops, and encourage some diversification.

- Challenges: Market access and infrastructure remain concerns. Technical support and streamlining implementation are crucial.

- Overall, government initiatives play a vital role but require further improvement to fully encourage crop diversification.

Remember: These are just sample answers. It’s important to further research and refine your responses based on your own understanding and perspective. Read entire UPSC Current Affairs.

Relevance to the UPSC Prelims and Mains syllabus under the following topics:

Prelims:

- General Studies 1: “Agriculture:” under the GS Paper III – Geography section. However, focusing on core syllabus topics like agricultural practices, types of crops, or irrigation methods would be a more strategic approach for Prelims.

Mains:

- Paper I – Indian Society (250 Marks):
  Issues related to agriculture (This editorial explores the challenges and potential benefits of agricultural practices in West Bengal)
  Rural development (The shift towards alternative crops can impact rural livelihoods)
- Paper II – Governance, Constitution, Public Administration (250 Marks):
  Government policies and interventions for development (This editorial discusses various government initiatives for crop diversification)
  Issues related to planning and management of water resources (Water scarcity is a factor driving crop diversification)
- Paper III – Indian Economy (250 Marks):
  Growth and development of agriculture (Crop diversification can contribute to agricultural growth and development in West Bengal)
  Factors affecting agriculture and allied sectors (The editorial highlights factors like market access and infrastructure impacting agriculture)